Rozumím dobře J. Bouška?
Jestli ano takže:
Zetor 5511 + 5t vlek
Měřítko: 1:32
Vydavatel: PMHT
Cena: 125 kč ,-
Formát sešitu: A4
Počet stran s díly: 4,5
Počet stran s návodem: 1
Počet stran s kresbami: 1,5
Velikost modelu:
délka: 110 + 150 mm
šířka: 60 + 70 mm
výška: 75 mm
Doplňky: Laserem vypálené dezény od firmy GPM
Nevieš kam dať 2% dane?. A čo tak prispieť na chod našej najväčšej súťaže v Nitre?
Nevieš ako? Napíš správu Radkovi ( RKK) , on ti povie ako na to. Ďakujeme.
Nevieš ako? Napíš správu Radkovi ( RKK) , on ti povie ako na to. Ďakujeme.
agromodels.cz
Moderátor: Trak-Tor
Re: Kirovets K700 /OREL/ 1:32
Hi guys!
It is not pleasant to tell for me but my models was stolen by czech author Jiří Bouška. In 2006 I created a paper model of a tractor Kirovets K-700, which was published in Ukrainian publishing house "Orel". You can find process of testing this model there. I was very surprised when I saw this version of the model. In a detailed study I found that 59 out of 123 parts of my models have been completely copied into his work (to a tenth of a millimeter with the same coloring), and another 19 were slightly modified (I did not take into account the details are made of wire, as in his model not specified). Given the highly simplified structure of the model is difficult to imagine that two independent developer could create the same parts as the same way. This suggests that his model - a modified my model.
This model was my first model, therefore I had built it twice in different CAD-program. It was simply a test of opportunities of programs. But owner of publishing house "Orel" proposed me to publish model, and I accepted this offer. I planed simple model and I used style of old Czech publishing house "ABC". You can find all process of creating on that page. Also you can find screenshot of CAD-programs on that page.
I have known Jiří Bouška has two models, but these models very different and old model has nothing in common with new model.
I can demonstrate it on some examples (images are clickable).
The old build schemes has nothing in common with the new model, but they copied my schemes:
The old part is very different from the new, but it copied my model constructively in all details:
The old part has some mistakes and is constructed in other way, but the new part copied my:
And I can find less then ten new details which are a little bit equal with old, but other parts are fully mine.
Author denies this issue, but I think you can see it yourself. Also you can find all our conversation there.
It is not pleasant to tell for me but my models was stolen by czech author Jiří Bouška. In 2006 I created a paper model of a tractor Kirovets K-700, which was published in Ukrainian publishing house "Orel". You can find process of testing this model there. I was very surprised when I saw this version of the model. In a detailed study I found that 59 out of 123 parts of my models have been completely copied into his work (to a tenth of a millimeter with the same coloring), and another 19 were slightly modified (I did not take into account the details are made of wire, as in his model not specified). Given the highly simplified structure of the model is difficult to imagine that two independent developer could create the same parts as the same way. This suggests that his model - a modified my model.
This model was my first model, therefore I had built it twice in different CAD-program. It was simply a test of opportunities of programs. But owner of publishing house "Orel" proposed me to publish model, and I accepted this offer. I planed simple model and I used style of old Czech publishing house "ABC". You can find all process of creating on that page. Also you can find screenshot of CAD-programs on that page.
I have known Jiří Bouška has two models, but these models very different and old model has nothing in common with new model.
I can demonstrate it on some examples (images are clickable).
The old build schemes has nothing in common with the new model, but they copied my schemes:
The old part is very different from the new, but it copied my model constructively in all details:
The old part has some mistakes and is constructed in other way, but the new part copied my:
And I can find less then ten new details which are a little bit equal with old, but other parts are fully mine.
Author denies this issue, but I think you can see it yourself. Also you can find all our conversation there.
Kto je prítomný
Užívatelia prezerajúci toto fórum: Žiadny pripojení užívatelia a 3 neregistrovaní